Glossary entry

German term or phrase:

Materialgerechtigkeit

English translation:

truth to material

Added to glossary by sats
Jun 12, 2009 08:53
15 yrs ago
2 viewers *
German term

Materialgerechtigkeit

German to English Art/Literary Art, Arts & Crafts, Painting
Alle Prinzipien des Funktionalismus scheinen außer Kraft gesetzt: die harmonische Übereinstimmung, die "Materialgerechtigkeit" im Einklang mit Form und Funktion......

This is a real "goody" - used rather frequently in German art/design texts yet unavailable in glossaries/dictionaries.... "material appropriateness" simply sounds awful --- Thanks for anybody who might know the established English term (if there is one)

Proposed translations

+2
40 mins
Selected

truth to material; (longhand: ) the use of materials for their inherent qualities

truth to material is widespread in art & archit. (albeit literally "Materialtreue" but I think it evoves the same exploiting of sth. for its own characteristics - in archit., cf. Brutalism (at best not brutal but 'brute' as in 'raw', exploits versatility and appearance of concrete etc. As much about appropriate/germane use & treatment of material as it is about the choice of a material appropriate to its purpose in situ (one sense often interlocking with t'other in any case).

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 41 mins (2009-06-12 09:34:55 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

( - as in asker's sentence)

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 46 mins (2009-06-12 09:39:36 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

/ which I hope explains why I kept my response to Gillian's & Samuel's answers 'neutral'. Further context may well go their way.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2 hrs (2009-06-12 11:52:44 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

No-one evoves, of course. Evokes.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 3 hrs (2009-06-12 12:19:05 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Exceptionally, a digression please - @Henry, looking at your profile says "P" hoch-zwei not least for the Russian lit. Frankly, I've been too lazy, so far, to bother (with "P", AND mea culpa, with Russ. lit). But for an art scholar (where the shouts of "Formidable", "cogent", etc.?), how about Helen. I'll end there or we'll be accused of being a mutual adulation club!
Note from asker:
Thanks Stephen and Helen - I agree 100% with both of you in this context. Thanks also to everybody else for their suggestions!
Peer comment(s):

agree Henry Schroeder : From a language perspective I don't like it, but it's bad to argue with Stephen.
11 mins
Hi, Henry, been ages, all well, as I hope chez toi. More @ your entry
agree Helen Shiner : Truth to material/s is the correct term, no contest.//see my ref. post.
1 hr
Thanks, Helen. But (Henry) please everyone argue!
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
5 mins

appropriateness/suitability of the material(s)

would do the trick
Peer comment(s):

neutral Stephen Reader : Depends on further contx.; yours suggests a material that (e.g.) harmonises visually or as a resource, with the environment ('sustainable' etc.); my 1st impr'n is optimum use of materials for their inherent quals. / to below: Not 'agree' but see my a
27 mins
why neutral for me and an agree with Samuel's identical answer? Appropriate/suitable covers a wide range of possibilities
agree BrigitteHilgner : "suitability" war auch mein spontaner Gedanke.
1 hr
disagree Helen Shiner : Sorry, but the term in very widespread use is 'truth to material/s' as Stephen has it.
1 hr
Something went wrong...
6 mins

suitability of materials

This might seem like a quick fix solution, but it is clearly a widely used term in metallurgy and many other fields.

For your sentence, you could put "the suitability of materials in harmony with form and function...."

www.globalspec.com/reference/6005/Suitability-of-Materials-...

www.evaluationengineering.com/archive/articles/0906/0906ass...
Peer comment(s):

agree GT-Translations
22 mins
neutral Stephen Reader : See mine @ Gillian, but your e.g. persuades.
27 mins
disagree Helen Shiner : Sorry to disagree, but to guide the Asker, 'truth to material/s' is the correct term in this field.
1 hr
Something went wrong...
41 mins

aptness of the material(s)

..another possibility
Something went wrong...
48 mins

material transeption

or "material aptness"

In other words I would make it up. And coming from a literary perspective, I would choose something that sounds good.

"transeption" is derived from transept, which I would use metaphorically with its implied appropriateness/correctness.

"arightness" would be a little more normal, but sounds much better than words like appropriate, etc.
Peer comment(s):

agree Stephen Reader : Arightness only/Oomph, H. - really dunno. Paradoxically, you may be being 2 language-sensitive/discerning for the contxt (of which there's little)? Depends how literary the source. But aright.'s elegant, has a ring, covers truth both to mtl. & end-use.
34 mins
You're probably right, but tell me something else: why in X's name do you not have a red P by your name. You are the Art Authority here! Proz.com gave it to a dileatant like me without my even requesting it. No offer to you is a grievous mistake!!!!!!
disagree Helen Shiner : Sorry, but I believe Stephen is on the right track, and has the correct term in this field.
56 mins
Something went wrong...
6 hrs

the choice of material befitting form and function

I believe they mean to say in a roundabout way 'the right stuff for the given purpose '
Something went wrong...

Reference comments

1 hr
Reference:

Truth to materials

Truth to materials is a tenet of modern architecture (as opposed to postmodern architecture), which holds that any material should be used where it is most appropriate and its nature should not be hidden. Concrete, therefore, should not be painted and the means of its construction should be celebrated – by, for instance, not sanding away marks left by timber shuttering (béton brut). As another example, porcelain is infrequently used in the exterior facing of buildings, but one modern example is the Dakin Building, Brisbane, California; therefore, the porcelain panels of this building have been left uncovered by any paint or preservative.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth_to_materials

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 hr (2009-06-12 10:41:30 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

For a critical discussion of the term's history see :


Günter Bandmann: Der Wandel der Materialbewertung in der Kunsttheorie des 19. Jahrhunderts, in: Helmut Koopmann, J. Adolf Schmoll gen. Eisenwerth (Ed.): Beiträge zur Theorie der Künste im 19. Jahrhundert, 2 Vol., Vol. 1, Frankfurt/M. 1971, p. 129-157.


Materialstil, Materialstimmung, Materialgerechtigkeit, in: Dietmar Rübel, Monika Wagner, Vera Wolff (Ed.): Materialästhetik. Quellentexte zu Kunst, Design und Architektur, Berlin 2005 ( ISBN 3-496-01335-4) This principle was also followed by the Chicago school of architecture and Louis Sullivan.

[also from the above link]

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 hr (2009-06-12 10:47:21 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=o1tZpr06WPsC&pg=PA373&lpg...

Book Description: Ostfildern-Ruit, Hatje Cantz, 2004**, 2004. Bound, grey cardboard wrappers, pictorial dustjacket, photo - frontispice, 210 x 275mm., 223pp., richely illustrated in color and b/w. Egon Eiermann was one of Germany's greatest twentieth-century architects. His works, which enjoy recognition worldwide, are characterized by transparency, truth to materials, high artistic standards, and stringent design quality down to the smallest detail. His pavilions fot the Federal Republic at the 1958 Brussels World's Fair established his international reputation while making him an architectural ambassador of the young German democracy. Using predominantly original photographs, the present publication offers a vivid portrait of Eiermann's architecture, while distinguished authorities on his work explore his philosophy and personality in a series of essays. Book is new. Bookseller Inventory # 16875
http://www.abebooks.co.uk/search/sortby/3/an/Annemarie Jaegg...

Since the mid-19th century, first in architecture, then in sculpture, and finally in painting, artists began to realize the expressive, symbolic and style-shaping characteristics of materials, calling for ‘Truth to Materials’ or ‘Materialgerechtigkeit’ in aesthetics.[17] Initial movements in architecture criticized the painting of buildings as ‘lying’, because layers of paint would hide the natural building materials. At the dawn of ‘artificial’ building materials, like concrete, materials came into the focus of the aesthetic natural-artificial debate in architecture, which was basically a debate between romanticism and futurism. Late 19th-century sculptors started trying out new or rediscovering old materials, beyond the obligatory bronze and marble. Degas’ wax statues of young girls were early modest, though scandalous, examples because the flesh-like colored wax provided the statues with a peculiarly sensual flair.[18] Much more radical, regarding both the variety of materials and the dominance of ‘matter over form’, were the objets trouvées or the arbitrarily assembled pieces of garbage of the Dadaists.
http://zdch.amu.edu.pl:8000/FMPro?-db=kursyv.fp5&-format=iss...

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 hr (2009-06-12 10:52:11 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Anytime, sats! Glad to help.
Note from asker:
Thanks a lot for your effort, Helen :-) A bugger text with just too many terms I need to research and failed with this one. Been very helpful!
Peer comments on this reference comment:

agree Stephen Reader : Nägel mit Köpfen if ever there were. LG/ Stephen
1 hr
Thanks, Stephen
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search